Translate

Search This Blog

Friday, 31 July 2009

Philosophy, Hypocrisy, and Public Libraries


A delightful week spent in the company of Swiss philosopher and political theorist Monika Maria Trost, with wide-ranging discussions on such diverse matters as Post-Modernism (Does it have a Future?) and the novels and plays of Friedrich Dürrenmatt, interrupted only occasionally by a tallish English baritone demanding the return of "his" kleine Philosophin.

But some tantalising questions remain. Why, for instance, does the catalogue of Lancashire County Library admit to the possession of certain books by the political theorist Hannah Arendt and then, almost in the same breath, deny it? It all looks decidedly fishy to me, and upon this matter I have two theories. First, that librarians at LCC, in their role (self-appointed) as guardians of the public morality (remember librarians and Enid Blyton? While librarians in the US were fiercely defending the right to free speech, often in court, specky do-gooders in the Uk were banning non-PC books such as the Famous Five and Noddy, aided and abetted by their colleagues-in-arms, half-educated teachers) have collectively decided that some subjects are to be kept from the eyes of the general reader lest the general reader be a pervert, and the Holocaust is top of the list. Or Second, that the new library assistant, Dulciedora, is to be given the job of weeding out the stuff that nobody reads so as to make room for pop CDs and DVDs and all the exciting books about TV shows like Big Brother, DIY welly maintenance and chick-lit novels for the lonely one-hander. And if you think Dulciedora doesn't exist, believe me, she does, and she and her tribe of clones are employed in every public library in the land, exercising their uncritical and uninformed judgment to extirpate books for which the public purse has paid probably millions of pounds, and if this is not a national scandal I don't know what is. My bookshelves are stuffed with irreplaceable and priceless books that Dulcie in one public library or another has decided are no longer needed - catalogues raisonnés of the works of Henry Moore and of Barbara Hepworth (this one printed on a selection of very fine rag papers), for example, and the long-OP first novel (1949) by Antony Burgess, A Vision of Battlements.

So it's either conspiracy theory or Dulcie "chuck it out, 'cos it's old an' borin' " Dora, and this time the application of Occam's Razor doesn't deliver the goods.

I fully expect Monika Maria Trost to invite me to be interviewed on her Sunday morning philosophy programme on Swiss TV so that I can blow the whistle on post-modernists and English public libraries. After all, she loves my cherry scones. I mean, anyone can render the Iliad into idiomatic Deutsch, but can they cook the perfect cherry scone? Hm?

It is only a matter of time...








Thursday, 30 July 2009

Barry Acne - the Hidden Diaries

Friends of Barry Acne (15), Church Organist and Choirmaster by profession may like to know that Barry's secret diaries are now appearing, in tantalisingly small chunks, on Barry's own blog.

Barry's diary starts a few days after his new vicar (called Ken) gave him a task - to produce a list of all the musical instruments mentioned in the Bible, and excused him organ duties while the task was in progress.

Click and read on...

Wednesday, 22 July 2009

Bumbledom - 2


You will remember that I have a friend who, because of a slight mix-up in the Register Office, had a daughter who didn't officially exist, and who had to affirm that she was indeed present at the birth of said daughter, something occasioning many a smile, even guffaw, from those innocents happily unacquainted with the labyrinthine ways and byways of bureaucracy.

Well, there is a happy ending, ish. For another registrar, just after the affirmation ceremony and no doubt while a hefty bill was being prepared, suddenly remembered an interesting point, hitherto overlooked - that birth certificates are but copies, allegedly accurate copies, of the entries in the original register. "And that must be in the strongroom..."

It was. And it bore the correct date of birth (mother had remembered it quite well, being, as we don't need to be reminded, there at the time.) But betwixt and between the original entry and the certificate of birth a small error had crept in. Only a small one - the wrong day.

So happy mother, happy daughter, and happy registrar. And, best of all, no hefty bill.

But how fortunate that mother is still with us, and not regaling the angels in heaven with merry anecdotes about being a wife of the Cloth, otherwise her daughter would have had a bit of a problem when faced with implacable Bumbledom, being non-existent.

Oh, Dickens, would that thou wert alive at this hour!


Monday, 20 July 2009

Church Times - and do you remember Men Only?


I quite like Church Times. It concentrates its attentions on matters of doctrinal difference that men of the cloth debate most earnestly when they are not playing with their electric train sets. It is the voice of the Established Church-men.

But just once, could Church Times open its pages to women theologians, and not put them on Page 3? From St Teresa and Hildegaard of Bingen to Mother Theresa women have done the donkey-work of the church, looking after the flock instead of the frock, and baking cakes in case an important Bishop chanced by.

And if it were not for women, there would be no men of the church to strut their stuff, because, dear priests and bishops and archdeacons, you were all born of a woman like the rest of us. A woman who gave you life, but whom you now deny equality to, in this church of all possible churches.

Boys, it might be a good moment to put aside your toys. The old order is changing - and thank God.


Concomitance, or Communion in Both Kinds

So Anglicans in Blackburn are, for the time being, while the world is in another of its pandemic panics, denied their right enshrined in Article 30 of the 39 Articles to take Communion in both kinds (ie the bread AND the wine).


For Article 30 clearly states:


XXX. Of both Kinds.


The Cup of the Lord is not to be denied to the Lay-people: for both the parts of the Lord's Sacrament, by Christ's ordinance and commandment, ought to be ministered to all Christian men alike.


And no doubt ardent Henry VIII-ites are even now writing to the newspapers in protest at this apparent violation of the Common Law of the Anglican church.


Now sacramental theology can differ quite markedly depending on which brand of Christianity you have been brought up in, and the answer to the question "Can the Sacrament be fully administered in only one kind?" depends entirely on whether you are an Anglican, a Roman Catholic, a Lutheran, or an Eastern Orthodox Christian - and if you are a Roman Catholic, depending also on when you ask, for the Roman Catholic church has changed its mind a few times in the last 2,100 years, according to what those whom it regarded as its enemies in the other Christian communities were up to.


Authority for all sacramental observances has to derive from Scripture, and problems arise only when Scripture is capable of being interpreted in different ways - problems compounded by the possibility that original texts might have been mistranslated.




The following seems to be quite a neat summary of the position. The words are by James Cardinal Gibbons, Archbishop of Baltimore, writing in 1917.




Our Savior gave communion under both forms of bread and wine to His Apostles at the last Supper. Officiating Bishops and Priests are always required, except on Good Friday, to communicate under both kinds. But even the clergy of every rank, including the Pope, receive only of the consecrated bread unless when they celebrate Mass.

The Church teaches that Christ is contained whole and entire under each species; so that whoever communicates under the form of bread or of wine receives not a mutilated Sacrament or a divided Savior, but shares in the whole Sacrament as fully as if he participated in both forms. Hence, the layman who receives the consecrated Bread partakes as copiously of the body and blood of Christ as the officiating Priest who receives both consecrated elements.

Our Lord says: "I am the living bread which came down from Heaven. If any man eat of this bread, he shall live forever; and the bread which I will give is My flesh, for the life of the world. ... He that eateth Me the same also shall live by Me. He that eateth this bread shall live forever." [John vi. 51, and seq.]

From this passage it is evident that whoever partakes of the form of bread partakes of the living flesh of Jesus Christ, which is inseparable from His blood, and which, being now in a glorious state, cannot be divided; for, "Christ rising from the dead, dieth now no more." [Rom. vi. 9.] Our Lord, in His words quoted, makes no reference to the sacramental cup, but only to the Eucharistic bread, to which He ascribes all the efficacy which is attached to communion under both kinds, viz., union with Him, spiritual life, eternal salvation.

St. Paul, writing to the Corinthians, says: "Whosoever shall eat this bread, or drink the chalice of the Lord unworthily, shall be guilty of the body and of the blood of the Lord." [I. Cor. xi. 27.] The Apostle here plainly declares that, by an unworthy participation in the Lord's Supper, under the form of either bread or wine, we profane both the body and the blood of Christ. How could this be so, unless Christ is entirely contained under each species? So forcibly, indeed, did the Apostle assert the Catholic doctrine that the Protestant translators have perverted the text by rendering it: "Whosoever shall eat this bread and drink the chalice," substituting and for or, in contradiction to the Greek original, of which the Catholic version is an exact translation.

It is also the received doctrine of the Fathers that the Eucharist is contained in all its integrity either in the consecrated bread or in the chalice. St. Augustine, who may be taken as a sample of the rest, says that "each one receives Christ the Lord entire under each particle." [Aug. De consec. dist.]

Luther himself, even after his revolt, was so clearly convinced of this truth that he was an uncompromising advocate of communion under one kind. "If any Council," he says, "should decree or permit both species, we would by no means acquiesce; but, in spite of the Council and its statute, we would use one form, or neither, and never both." [De formula Missae.]

Leibnitz, the eminent Protestant divine, observes: "It cannot be denied that Christ is received entire by virtue of concomitance, under each species; nor is His flesh separated from His blood." [Systema Theol., p. 250.]

As the same virtue is contained in the Sacrament, whether administered in one or both forms, the faithful gain nothing by receiving under both kinds, and lose nothing by receiving under one form. Consequently, we nowhere find our Savior requiring the communion to be administered to the faithful under both forms; but He has left this matter to be regulated by the wisdom and discretion of the Church, as He has done with regard to the manner of administering Baptism.

Our Redeemer, it is true, has said: "Drink ye all of this." But it should be remembered that these words were addressed not to the people at large, but only to the Apostles, who alone were also commanded, on the same occasion, to consecrate His body and blood in remembrance of Him. Now we have no more right to infer that the faithful are obliged to drink of the cup, because the Apostles were commanded to drink of it, than we have to suppose that the laity are required or allowed to consecrate the bread and wine, because the power of doing so was at the last Supper conferred on the Apostles.

It is true also that our Lord said to the people: "Unless ye eat the flesh of the Son of man, and drink His blood, ye shall not have life in you." But this command is literally fulfilled by the laity when they partake of the consecrated bread, which, as we have seen, contains Christ the Lord in all His integrity. Hence, if our Savior has said: "Whoso eateth My flesh, and drinketh My blood, hath everlasting life," He has also said, "The bread which I will give is My flesh, for the life of the world."


The swine 'flu epidemic has caused all of us to consider matters of hygiene more carefully, bishops as well as the rest of us. Indeed, the (Roman Catholic) diocese of Plymouth banned the administration of the chalice to the laity three weeks before + Blackburn, and + Chelmsford has told parishes to stop using stoups of water that has been blessed. Sensible precautions, you might think.


So just in case Bishop Nicholas starts getting flak from the red-top papers, whose general idea of news is a photograph of a lady in the buff, and who think that sinners against red-top orthodoxy should be chased from the kingdom, especially if they are paediatricians, can we remember that as Christians we are subject to the discipline of our Church, just as much as monks and nuns in their houses that are both of this world and the next are, and that there is just about as much wisdom and thought to be found in a tabloid newspaper as there is in a cream bun?

A bishop's directive is law to the diocesan clergy, and therefore it is law to the laity. It is not something that PCCs can vote on.

There are two valuable lessons to learn from all this. One: every age reinterprets matters of faith in the light of new knowledge, and Christianity has been remarkably robust in the face of challenges from the secular world following scientific and philosophical advances in understanding. And two: the laity (and the clergy!) don't get burnt at the stake any more for asking awkward questions or expressing unorthodox opinions. Phew.


Wednesday, 15 July 2009

What is the CofE coming to? Applause for the Organist?


A wonderful experience last Sunday, while doing a bit of guesting for Evensong in a choir a few miles away. Nothing to do with the singing (which was wonderful, for the participants, at least), but for what happened after the service. Despite the lure of biccies and Fairtrade coffee and a post-service chat, people were glued to their congregational seats - actually listening to the organist's voluntary. But the best thing was that when he finished, they, the congregation, and we, the choir bods, burst out in spontaneous applause. I have never before, in more than 50 years of church musicking, heard or seen that happen, even in a cathedral, and I dare say there were quite of few of us there whose hearts leapt for sheer joy.

I'm going to have to mention it to my friend Barry Acne - I mean, Barry, the organist warmed up with the Karg-Elert thing, and only so that he could set his pistons!

Monday, 13 July 2009

Vive la belle France, et ses sacrées Dimanches


Trés intéressant, n'est-ce-pas?

This man formidable, Sarko, desires to follow the example British and render his country a seven-day zone Shopping et Sport, and I do wish he wouldn't, as do many of his own countrymen and women, who are rising up en masse to protect the traditional French Sunday - mornings spent discharging cartridges from lethal weapons at small animals a-nibbling of the verdant meadows or at passing charabancs a-packed with English tourists a-nibbling at their butties, and then a well-earned four-hour luncheon featuring some, if not all, of the morning's targets (though luckily the Geneva Convention forbids the consumption of English tourists, en croûte or otherwise, even in France, where they would eat a brick wall if it was properly cooked and served with a sauce appropriate, but rabbits and hares and small songbirds do not, at least as far as I am aware, receive mention in said Convention), not to mention several litres of the wine home-brewed.

I blame it all on his missis, who is absolutely gorgeous and not a bad singist in the popular vein, but she is of course Italian, and in Italy anything goes.

I mean, can you imagine Carla Bruni hitting it off with Konrad Adenaur or Willy Brandt? For heaven's sake, in Germany the shops close at lunchtime on Saturday and don't open again until Monday morning, for everyone will be at prayer in their cold northern-Europeanly manner. No wonder she opted for Sarko - he's young, he's a bit of a rebel, and he is wickedly French.

I don't know what it is about the English and the French that makes them dislike each other so much, apart from Agincourt, of course, which was a bit unfair, the French lot being led by a dolphin, by all accounts, so what chance did they have? I mean, we English don't have to look across the Channel to find aliens who talk funny to poke fun at - for most of us Wales is a lot nearer. We profess to hate the French and the Welsh, and we tell very funny (and racist, if you want to be pompous and humourless) jokes against them, but we want to buy retirement houses there, as though they will all say "Oh, you English with your sense of humour funny, how nice that you desire to live amongst us, is it not that it is, look you?"

But if Sarko thinks he can legislate against the traditional French Sunday, he is in for a surprise. He leads the awkwardest, most stubborn nation on earth, with the most beautiful and musical language on earth, where everybody is a philosopher from birth and the only shops that open on a Sunday are the ones that sell bread unless they are a restaurant. And after all, French Sundays are so spiritually inspiring that museums and art galleries have to have Mondays off to recover.

We don't want France, or Italy, or Germany, or Austria, or Belgium, or even Poland, to lose their outrageous differences in a synthetic, amorphous grey glob of conforming Europeanism, do we? I know I don't, me.

So I do wish that the utterly delectable and probably fragrant Carla would have a word in Sarko's oreilles shell-like. I mean, she's Italian. She probably takes two hours to dress up and put the slap on in order to ride the Vespa to the shop next door for a packet of fags. The Entente Cordiale doesn't mean that France has to do the same moronic things that the English do of a Sunday, both of which begin with an f - football, and effing shopping.

Vive la France! Vive la différence! And especially vivent M. le Président et Mme Carla, phwoar.





Favoured Blogs List

Followers